Pdf philosophys betrayal of wagner to schopenhauer mike. Instead wagner was well aware of the lines of thought of what we call essential and vital philosophy, not in detail but in its. Wagner and the philosophy of revolutionbbc radio 3. Pascals wager, practical argument for belief in god formulated by blaise pascal. In this radically clarifying book, bryan magee traces wagners.
He was especially interested in german idealism but he was always creative in appropriating the thought of figures such as hegel, feuerbach and schopenhauer. The assumption, commonly expressed, that wagner was much influenced by nietzsche, is mistaken, at least in the sense normally intended. Richard wagners published writings present various topoi to which he returned repeatedly. As magee shows, wagner s thinking should not be too readily dismissed. Weve had an error looking up if you have access to this title. In response, wagner composed works such as tristan and isolde and parsifal whose libretti are pervaded with.
The idea of philosophy somehow betraying or letting down wagner may also need explaining since analyses of wagners earlier works often lead to the conclusion that he was an unconscious schopenhauerian long before he ever read schopenhauer. Wagner warned nietzsche to be wary of ree on account of his being jewish. Richard wagner 181883 was one of the most significant opera composers of his time. Professor christopher janaway on wagner s lifechanging encounter with the pessimistic philosophy of arthur schopenhauer. Books wagner and philosophy by bryan magee ralph blumenau devours bryan magees new book about wagner the philosophical composer in 1968 bryan magee published an influential little book called aspects of wagner now in an oup paperback and then, in 1983, a magisterial work, the philosophy of schopenhauer also now in an oup paperback. Wagner and philosophy by bryan magee a profoundly searching investigation that reveals for the first time the philosophical foundations of wagner s art richard wagner s devotees have ranged from the subtlest minds proust to the most brutal hitler. William cord, a wagnerian researcher, goes as far as to say that. He worked out many of the details in the late 1840s and early 1850s and used them as the basis for the ring, tristan, meistersinger and parsifal. Wagners historiographic approach is reflected in his discussions of the greek influence on music.
This book was a major explicator of all these themes. Wagner was one of the few major composers who studied philosophy seriously. Wagner and german idealism art and music roger scruton the tristan chord. Outstanding among the many creative artists on whom schopenhauer exercised influence was the opera composer richard wagner 1883, who, rarely for a composer, was an intellectual and studied schopenhauers philosophy seriously. Many people encounter these basic human questions, not merely in spoken and written word, but in life. A polemical contribution to moral and political theory, it offers a critique of moral values and traces the historical evolution of concepts such as guilt, conscience, responsibility, law and justice. The project gutenberg ebook of the case of wagner, nietzsche contra wagner, and selected aphorisms.
Idea, teleology, providence and the death of god in. The philosophy is a clever weaving together of ideas primarily from david friedrich strauss. The case of wagner, nietzsche contra wagner, and selected. This is followed by an appendix discussing whether wagners antisemitism had any influence on his operas. A lot of opera lovers, including my wife, find his operas difficult and only listen to them under duress. Philosophy can be a tasting of truths, but it has to admit that its central category is emptyand indeed has to be, in order for it to wait in vain for, and when it finally arrives welcome, the event. The enduring fascination with his works arises not only from his singular fusion of musical innovation and theatrical daring, but also from his largely overlooked engagement with the boldest investigations of modern philosophy. Bryan magee places the composers artistic development in the context of the philosophy of his age, and gives us the first detailed and comprehensive study of the close links between wagner and the philosophers from the premarxist socialists to feuerbach and. First the music wagner as a young german wagner the leftwing revolutionary wagner, feuerbach and the future wagner s misleading reputation opera as greek drama some of the rings leading ideas wagner s discovery of schopenhauer the philosophy of schopenhauer wagner reevaluates his values the turn metaphysics. The effect of richard wagners music and beliefs on hitlers ideology.
A goodnatured, intelligent and musical friend of mine who once came to a party. In wagners music, in his doctrine, in his whole concept of art, nietzsche saw the confirmation, the promotion, even the encouragement, of that decadence and degeneration which is now rampant in europe. Sep 06, 2001 wagner was one of the few major composers who studied philosophy seriously. If the christian god does not exist, the agnostic loses little by believing in him and gains. In wagner s music, in his doctrine, in his whole concept of art, nietzsche saw the confirmation, the promotion, even the encouragement, of that decadence and degeneration which is now rampant in europe. Michael tanner looks at the relationship between two titans of german culture, the 55year old composer richard wagner and the precocious 24. The effect of richard wagners music and beliefs on hitlers. Bryan magee places the composers artistic development in the context of the philosophy of his age, and gives us the first detailed and comprehensive study of the close links between wagner and the philosophers from the premarxist socialists to feuerbach and schopenhauer. Ask questions about reality, knowledge, reasoning, language and conduct, and experience the hidden power of these basic human questions. Professor christopher janaway on wagners lifechanging encounter with the pessimistic philosophy of arthur schopenhauer. Whole piece if reading words like philosophy or schopenhauer make you want to run for the hills, just hang on.
Pdf julian young, the philosophies of richard wagner lanham. The effect of richard wagner s music and beliefs on hitlers ideology. Wagners philosophers idealism, revolution, schopenhauer. As magee shows, wagners thinking should not be too readily dismissed. Whereas anglophone publications devoted primarily to wagners philosophy might be rare,1 german scholarship on wagners writings has produced numerous. Nietzsche, wagner and the philosophy of pessimism taylor. In addition to these two works he may have read the aesthetics and if he did not he must have learned about. In addition to being a great composer, richard wagner was also an important philosopher. This paper discusses how the philosophy of his time pushed richard wagner to the pessimism of schopenhauer, turning what could have been one of the greatest and most lifeaffirming composers into one of the greatest yet life denying composers. Pdf this article outlines richard wagners conception of. In this radically clarifying book, bryan magee traces wagner s.
Pdf wagner and philosophy download full pdf book download. Wagner was one of the few composers to read avidly in the areas of theology and philosophy. Best known for the challenging fouropera cycle the ring of the nibelung, richard wagner 18a83 was a conductor, librettist, theater director, and essayist, in addition to being the composer of some of the most enduring operatic works in history, such as the flying dutchman, tannhauser, and tristan and isolde. Nietzsche was decisively influenced by wagner, with an influence that was colossal and lifelong. The concept of randomness has given rise to three main currents of. The philosophy of richard wagner several, four, many. Magee, a british writer on philosophy, music, and theater criticism and a former member of parliament, has made a remarkable contribution to the already extensive literature on the life and works of. The effect of richard wagners music and beliefs on hitler. This article is taken from an appendix to the philosophy of schopenhauer. Philosophy and religious studies department at wagner college.
Nietzsche suspected that wagner was motivated in this by a desire for success and popularity rather than by authentic artistic reasons. From library journal magee, a british writer on philosophy, music, and theater criticism and a former member of parliament, has. Wagner is a composer with a brilliant ability to convey ideas in music, and that makes the philosophical issues were going to delve into much more directly accessible and enjoyable, than they might appear as words on a page. This ebook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. Mar 02, 2018 richard wagner is discussed in relation with hegel and german idealism, the philosophy of revolution, schopenhauer, nietzsche, and theodor adorno. He was already composing operas in accordance with a published theory of his own, which involved treating all its constituent elements as of equal importance. The books greatest highlight for me was a precis on kants philosophy and how it linked with schopenhauers eventual world view.
May 04, 2016 in addition to being a great composer, richard wagner was also an important philosopher. Bryan magee wagner and philosophy by bryan magee, 9780140295191, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Wagner used the second edition of 184012 and this was the only work of modern philosophy in wagners personal library in dresden and he dates the first reading to 1847. It is absurd to claim that the philosophy of wagner, creator of the torrential. Richard wagner s devotees have ranged from the subtlest minds proust to the most brutal hitler. Twilight of t he idols university of massachusetts boston. Some points of relevance for contemporary monetary scholarship richard e. The holocaust will always be remembered as one of the most horrific and evil events in all of history. The case against wagner was one nietzsches last books, and his wittiest. Nietzsches relationship with wagner has long been a source of controversy and has given rise to a number of important studies, including this major breakthrough in nietzsche scholarship, first published in 1982. Free the philosophies of richard wagner pdf download julian young presents richard wagner as an important philosopher of art and life first as a utopian anarchistcommunist and later as a schopenhauerian pessimist understanding wagner s philosophy is crucial to understanding his operas. There is a clear and consistent philosophy behind the music dramas of richard wagner. You may copy it, give it away or reuse it under the terms of the project gutenberg.
Wagner department of economics george mason university fairfax, va 22030, usa abstract this paper explores five topics where georg simmels philosophy of money poses challenges for contemporary monetary scholarship. Download the philosophies of richard wagner pdf summary. Wagner was one of the very few really great com posers who was an intellectual in the sense of taking. Wagner was not a philosopher, and in reality he was never truly interested in philosophy and science as system and according to the concepts called professional. Well explore the ancient and modern realms of metaphysics, epistemology, logic, and ethics, as well as questions on the nature of politics, society, law, medicine, and art. Wagner and philosophy by bryan magee issue 34 philosophy now. Bbc radio 3 the essay, wagners philosophers, wagner and. Mar 06, 20 the philosophy of richard wagner there is a clear and consistent philosophy behind the music dramas of richard wagner. For a refutation of this view, see laubichler et al. In 1968 bryan magee published an influential little book called aspects of wagner now in an oup paperback and then, in 1983, a magisterial work, the philosophy of schopenhauer also now in an oup paperback. Wagner and philosophy by bryan magee the tristan chord.
Mapping the influence of ideas on wagners art, magee shows how abstract thought can permeate musical work and. He was awesomely wellread in the philosophy, philology and linguistics of his day, in. But this is not because wagner was an important philosopher. Sep 02, 2015 10december20 wagner and the philosophy of revolution professor anthony grayling looks at the crucial years before and after the dresden uprising of 1849 when wagner was manning the. Richard wagner is discussed in relation with hegel and german idealism, the philosophy of revolution, schopenhauer, nietzsche, and theodor adorno. Richard wagners devotees have ranged from the subtlest minds proust to the most brutal hitler. Pdf philosophys betrayal of wagner to schopenhauer. Julian young begins by examining the philosophy of art and society wagner constructs during his time as a revolutionary anarchistcommunist.
702 1350 996 1065 799 284 1276 147 1445 1188 39 75 1266 721 31 1436 1294 862 249 607 1129 724 1554 973 811 396 392 1307 241 1550 1395 313 495 5 435 1284 1038 759 196 1306 760 230 398